Print Page | Close Window

Wiring 2 speakers and a tweeter

Printed From: Speakerplans.com
Category: General
Forum Name: Newbie Discussion
Forum Description: Newbie Discussion/Questions. Look less stupid here...
URL: https://forum.speakerplans.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=69080
Printed Date: 19 April 2024 at 5:10am
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 12.06 - https://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: Wiring 2 speakers and a tweeter
Posted By: Andygee70
Subject: Wiring 2 speakers and a tweeter
Date Posted: 18 July 2012 at 10:58pm
Hi there all you experienced speaker-people, I want to join your club and I need your help! So...

It's with a certain amount of embarassment that my first post is probably one of the simplest things you can achieve, but for a week now I've been googling the WWW for exactly what I've posted in the thread title, and the result?? Nothing that helps someone of my experience, which is more PA setting-up with the band I play with plus a basic understanding of Ohms and speaker tolerance together with cabling. Before anyone jumps to any conclusions I've even bought a book on speaker building and I understood the cabinet building and the speaker selection bits, but the wiring flew right above my head. The parallel and series wiring was straight forward, but anything more complicated was beyond me, unfortunately. Bearing in mind I can set up our full, 3-way 5Kw PA system (purchased, not built) without any worries, but I'm wanting to build some speaker cabinets to get the most out of our amplifiers, which the present speakers do not. So having replaced the sub-woofers last week (easiest of the jobs), replacing the 20-year-old McCauley 400W @ 8 Ohm speakers with 2 Eminence Kilomax 18, 1300W @ 4 Ohm - it's given our PA system an instant 1.8Kw increase. The amps can handle it because we have 3 x Peavey PV3800 which can throw out 1300W per side @ 4 Ohms.

So, my problem lies in wanting to build a mid range speaker cabinet (woodwork sorted) that will house 2 x 15" 500W speakers @ 8 Ohms and a 45W 1" Tweeter @ 8 Ohms (all Eminence). I'm trying to build a 1000W 4 Ohm cabinet for the mid-range Peavey PV3800. My idea was to link all the speakers and tweeter in parallel thus reducing the speakers to a 4 Ohm load and getting the full power out of the amp. I know how to wire the two speakers in parallel ( + to + & - to -) but how to incorporate a tweeter in that circuit, I have no idea. I know a crossover of some sort is required, but where it goes, what type it should be, I'm totally lost.

That's basically it and I'm sorry for the ramblings, if I could have found this info on a website somewhere I would have, and saved you the bother of answering the ramblings of a Welsh man.

Thank you for reading and if you have the answer, thank you once more Confused



Replies:
Posted By: Elliot Thompson
Date Posted: 19 July 2012 at 2:57am
Hi.

If you are looking for a simplistic method, buy a capacitor. Attach the capacitor between the positive terminal of the tweeter and, positive wire of the loudspeaker cable.

Pending on where you would like your tweeter crossed, you can purchase one of the following capacitors:

These are rough estimate figures

5.0uF = 4 kHz

4.0uF = 5 kHz

3.5uF = 5.5 kHz

3uF = 6.5 kHz

2.5uF = 8 kHz

2.0uF = 10 kHz

http://www.bluearan.co.uk/index.php?browsemode=category&category=Speaker_Components&masthead=Crossover_Components&subheadnew=Capacitors" rel="nofollow - http://www.bluearan.co.uk/index.php?browsemode=category&category=Speaker_Components&masthead=Crossover_Components&subheadnew=Capacitors


Best Regards,



-------------
Elliot Thompson


Posted By: lycantheleopard
Date Posted: 19 July 2012 at 3:59am
what you are building in escence is a yamaha sm215, uses eminence drivers as well, probably same compression driver but maybe different fifteens.
 
i am going to recomend a few things, having builtand referbeished a lot of boxes justlikeyou are considering here
 
1.  please give model numbers of the eminence speakers chosen for this project.
 
2.  when you refer to a tweeter, i'm guessing your thinking of a horn driver, something like the eminence psd 2002.  these really need a proper crossover and while a simple capasitor will get you there in the end, itsnot the best way to achieve good results.
 
3.  what horn with what dispursion are you going to put on this cab, what kinds of rooms and crowd sizes are you playing for.
 
4.  unless you are dead set on a 1 inch tweeter, i might recomend going to a 2 compression driver, eminence makes one that sounds good and is quite reasonably priced.  this would keep up better for vocals and guitar micing with the subs you already are running.
 
5.  keep in mind that 1300 watt rms rating on the eminence kilamax is a bit inflated, you will want to be a bit careful and understand that it is a good driver, though not imo the end all beat all eminence says it is.
 
6.  did you do any research and modeling to figure out cabinet tuning and such for the fifteens? good performance is not always about slapping a speaker in a box and hoping..though god knows i've done that enough times.
 
have fun, keep slogging along, and realize that your on the right path, there is just a lot more to consider.


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 19 July 2012 at 8:58am
Thank you guys for such quick and considered replies.

I was looking to load the cabinet (not yet built but have bought 18mm ply in anticipation) with 2 x Eminence Definimax 4015LF or their Kappa Pro - 15A speakers. The super tweeter I was going to use was their APT:200 tweeter, but if you think the 2" driver is a better option then I would bow down to your superior knowledge.  I've put some calcs into an online model program, but if truth be told I didn't really understand what I was reading.

We play to crowds that vary and we use the PA system accordingly. Can play to 500 people in the bigger clubs, but usually to crowds of 150 to 200 in the pubs.

We've got an outdoor festival that I'm organising at the end of August; 300 people outdoors max and all this is really in anticipation of that - so I have 6 weeks or so to sort these speakers out) and other PA work I'm hoping to take on - plud having a general interest in building my own speaker set-up.

Just to clarify, I want to do the same with the tops that I want to replace. So that all the system will be loaded with Eminence speakers. The same principle as the 15's really - loading 2 x Eminence Definimax 4012HO or the Kappa Pro - 12A with a horn/tweeter.

Currently we have the Eminence subs, 2 x Electrovoice ZX5's for the mids and Electrovoice 2 x ZX3's for the tops with digital crossover unit seperating the signal.

Any help with what I'm trying to do is really appreciated, as are the comments to date :-)


Posted By: joshd963
Date Posted: 19 July 2012 at 9:21am
Hi Andy,
 
I was in the same boat as you... I went for 2x10 inch drivers (8ohm) & a 1 inch tweeter horn (midtops for a lightweight portable club music rig)... all fane components. I finished one of them last night (aside from a lick of paint), I will upload some pics after work.
 
I would recommend using WinISD to calculate the size of box you need... there is a good guide available on the below link... I'm no expert on this program so i'd direct your questions about this program to someone other than myself Tongue
 
http://forum.speakerplans.com/guide-to-winisd-pro-and-hornresp_topic1314.html" rel="nofollow - http://forum.speakerplans.com/guide-to-winisd-pro-and-hornresp_topic1314.html
 
With regards to an internal crossover, if you already have a digital crossover, it might be much easier to go down the route that i went:
 
I wired the 2 10 inch drivers in parralell to bring the ohm down to 4... my amp prefers this.
 
I then wired the tweeter horn to a seperate plug on the back of the cabinet, and that goes into a different amp for the tweeters.
 
So i have two speakon sockets on the back of my speaker cab - one for the mid drivers and one for the tweeter.
 
You then need to look at crossover points... my drivers worked well cutting the mids out at 4.5khz, and then the tweeter horn kicked in from there all the way up to 20khz...
 
This is much more easily controlled when the signals are split and you can control it all from a digital crossover...
 
Hope this helps a little... please don't hesitate to ask more questions, we have all been in the same boat at some point in our speaker building lives!


Posted By: George C
Date Posted: 19 July 2012 at 1:17pm
Originally posted by Elliot Thompson Elliot Thompson wrote:

Hi.


These are rough estimate figures

5.0uF = 4 kHz

4.0uF = 5 kHz

3.5uF = 5.5 kHz

3uF = 6.5 kHz

2.5uF = 8 kHz

2.0uF = 10 kHz


Best Regards,



stupid question probably but -   are these capacitors limited power ratings or could I put them in any cab no matter rating of the cab, I am thinking of  450 W  

thanks  Big smile



Posted By: markie
Date Posted: 19 July 2012 at 3:58pm
In answer to the above,  capacitors have a voltage rating as well as the uF value so you would need caps of at least  250V for a 400 watt cab. having said that a single cap will not give the HF sufficient protection so you would be better of with a 2 way crossover.......... better still go to an active crossover.

Going from a pair of 15s to an APT200 is likely to leave a large hole in the  frequency response, you'd be better off with 10s as suggested above. Most 15s will be losing response from about 1500Hz and the APT doesn't start till 4000Hz.  Also 10s will in general give a much better vocal sound.

In case you don't understand those Hz thingies, the frequency of middle C is about 261Hz and the low C on a guitar (5th string 3rd fret) is 130.5Hz, each time the freq doubles the note goes up 1 full octave....... or each time it halves, the note goes down a full octave.




-------------
If it's got wheels or tits it's gonna cost a fortune


Posted By: Elliot Thompson
Date Posted: 19 July 2012 at 5:35pm

Originally posted by George C George C wrote:


Originally posted by Elliot Thompson Elliot Thompson wrote:

Hi.


These are rough estimate figures

5.0uF = 4 kHz

4.0uF = 5 kHz

3.5uF = 5.5 kHz

3uF = 6.5 kHz

2.5uF = 8 kHz

2.0uF = 10 kHz


Best Regards,


<div id="LCS_336D0C35_8A85_403a_B9D2_65C292C39087_communicationDiv">


stupid question probably but -   are these capacitors limited power ratings or could I put them in any cab no matter rating of the cab, I am thinking of  450 W  

thanks  Big smile




450 watts @ 8 ohms is 60 volts. Anything offering 60 volts or higher will be fine.

Bear in mind the values I wrote are based on an 8-ohm driver. If your drivers are not 8-ohms the frequency next the farad rating will differ.

Best Regards,

-------------
Elliot Thompson


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 19 July 2012 at 5:39pm
Originally posted by joshd963 joshd963 wrote:

Hi Andy,
 
I was in the same boat as you... I went for 2x10 inch drivers (8ohm) & a 1 inch tweeter horn (midtops for a lightweight portable club music rig)... all fane components. I finished one of them last night (aside from a lick of paint), I will upload some pics after work.
 
I would recommend using WinISD to calculate the size of box you need... there is a good guide available on the below link... I'm no expert on this program so i'd direct your questions about this program to someone other than myself Tongue
 
http://forum.speakerplans.com/guide-to-winisd-pro-and-hornresp_topic1314. - http://forum.speakerplans.com/guide-to-winisd-pro-and-hornresp_topic1314.html
 
With regards to an internal crossover, if you already have a digital crossover, it might be much easier to go down the route that i went:
 
I wired the 2 10 inch drivers in parralell to bring the ohm down to 4... my amp prefers this.
 
I then wired the tweeter horn to a seperate plug on the back of the cabinet, and that goes into a different amp for the tweeters.
 
So i have two speakon sockets on the back of my speaker cab - one for the mid drivers and one for the tweeter.
 
You then need to look at crossover points... my drivers worked well cutting the mids out at 4.5khz, and then the tweeter horn kicked in from there all the way up to 20khz...
 
This is much more easily controlled when the signals are split and you can control it all from a digital crossover...
 
Hope this helps a little... please don't hesitate to ask more questions, we have all been in the same boat at some point in our speaker building lives!


Hi Josh and thank you for your support.

The problem I have with the crossover unit is that it has 6 outputs, so I can't spare any just for the HFs. I'll definately check out WinISD - if it's easy to understand then fantastic, will be good for me because I want to build the cabinet to maximise the speakers.


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 19 July 2012 at 5:49pm
Originally posted by markie markie wrote:

In answer to the above,  capacitors have a voltage rating as well as the uF value so you would need caps of at least  250V for a 400 watt cab. having said that a single cap will not give the HF sufficient protection so you would be better of with a 2 way crossover.......... better still go to an active crossover.

Going from a pair of 15s to an APT200 is likely to leave a large hole in the  frequency response, you'd be better off with 10s as suggested above. Most 15s will be losing response from about 1500Hz and the APT doesn't start till 4000Hz.  Also 10s will in general give a much better vocal sound.

In case you don't understand those Hz thingies, the frequency of middle C is about 261Hz and the low C on a guitar (5th string 3rd fret) is 130.5Hz, each time the freq doubles the note goes up 1 full octave....... or each time it halves, the note goes down a full octave.




Well if it leaves a hole in the frequency  I don't have a problem going for the Eminence HF Drivers. They advertise the PSD:3006-8 on the site which is a 2" 100W HF Driver with the following specification:

Specification
Throat Size2", 50.8mm
Nominal Impedance*8 ohms
Power Rating**100W @ 800Hz
Free Air Resonace0.47kHz
Usable Frequency Range800Hz-20kHz
Sensitivity***109dB (1W/1m across 800Hz-20kHz)
Magnet Weight80oz, 2.27kg
Voice Coil Diameter3" / 76.2mm

I can see that the frequency range of the above overlaps the 15's so I'm assuming this would be an option?





Posted By: lycantheleopard
Date Posted: 19 July 2012 at 7:21pm
the ev cabs you have right now are actually very fine speakers and you arent really getting what they can fully do by using one pair as mids and one pair as tops, unless half of each is blown out lol..then your doing it right with what you have.
 
if i was you, with what you own, this is what i would do.
 
use two outputs of your crossover for the eighteens, two more for a pair of eminence capa pro 12s per side, and the final two for a pair of eminence psd3006.  scrap the four way idea, keep it simple, set xover points accordingly, and be loud as all get out, clean and clear, with less cabinets to move.
 
having a four way system is great, when you need it, but live bands dont need it nearly as much as dj/prerecorded music imo and..please dont take this the wrong way, it sounds like your biting off more than you can hold onto with this, and keeping it simpler for starters will net a better result especially if you've got six weeks before they need to be used.
 
down the road you could add four more eighteens and then some dedicate midbass/low midrange cabs with the eminence 4015 lf, but for now..the above is what i would do.
 
some other notes.
 
use a 90 x40 dispursion horn for the psd 3006, when you want to double up this rig later it will be harder to get the angles of two cabs per side right, but for now, its the best option for even coverage in pubs up to outdoors with one set of horns per side.
 
use crossover points of 90 hz lowpass to the eighteens, with a 30 hz highpass as well both 24db butterworth.
 
use crossover points of 110 hz highpass for the 12s and 1.1 khz for the lowpass of the 12s, 24db on the lowend and 18 at the top.  the reason for the gap between the highpass of the 12s or lowpass of the fifteens is that most pa setups tend to energize a room at about 100 hz and this creates a small null where the frequencies are less..meaning less eq and less mud right out of the box.
 
use highpass of 1.2 khz 24 db on the horns, and set the lowpass on the crossover to 20khz or out depending on what it can do.
 
these crossover points would also work if using the eminence cappa pro fifteen, but i really like the sound of 12s better for rock vocals and such.
 
these are starting figures and will get you going quick, then you can play with dropping the hf driver to 800..but dont overlap, if you drop the hf driver down, drop the 12s too.  setting the hf driver a little above 1khz nets you more protection and safety for the driver diafram.


Posted By: George C
Date Posted: 19 July 2012 at 7:26pm
thanks for replies to my 'stupid question', great information, some I knew - lots more confirmed what I thought..... 
 
Thumbs Up

George c


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 19 July 2012 at 10:38pm
Originally posted by lycantheleopard lycantheleopard wrote:

the ev cabs you have right now are actually very fine speakers and you arent really getting what they can fully do by using one pair as mids and one pair as tops, unless half of each is blown out lol..then your doing it right with what you have.
 
if i was you, with what you own, this is what i would do.
 
use two outputs of your crossover for the eighteens, two more for a pair of eminence capa pro 12s per side, and the final two for a pair of eminence psd3006.  scrap the four way idea, keep it simple, set xover points accordingly, and be loud as all get out, clean and clear, with less cabinets to move.
 
having a four way system is great, when you need it, but live bands dont need it nearly as much as dj/prerecorded music imo and..please dont take this the wrong way, it sounds like your biting off more than you can hold onto with this, and keeping it simpler for starters will net a better result especially if you've got six weeks before they need to be used.
 
down the road you could add four more eighteens and then some dedicate midbass/low midrange cabs with the eminence 4015 lf, but for now..the above is what i would do.
 
some other notes.
 
use a 90 x40 dispursion horn for the psd 3006, when you want to double up this rig later it will be harder to get the angles of two cabs per side right, but for now, its the best option for even coverage in pubs up to outdoors with one set of horns per side.
 
use crossover points of 90 hz lowpass to the eighteens, with a 30 hz highpass as well both 24db butterworth.
 
use crossover points of 110 hz highpass for the 12s and 1.1 khz for the lowpass of the 12s, 24db on the lowend and 18 at the top.  the reason for the gap between the highpass of the 12s or lowpass of the fifteens is that most pa setups tend to energize a room at about 100 hz and this creates a small null where the frequencies are less..meaning less eq and less mud right out of the box.
 
use highpass of 1.2 khz 24 db on the horns, and set the lowpass on the crossover to 20khz or out depending on what it can do.
 
these crossover points would also work if using the eminence cappa pro fifteen, but i really like the sound of 12s better for rock vocals and such.
 
these are starting figures and will get you going quick, then you can play with dropping the hf driver to 800..but dont overlap, if you drop the hf driver down, drop the 12s too.  setting the hf driver a little above 1khz nets you more protection and safety for the driver diafram.


I don't know if I understand the above post correctly, but the system I currently have is a 3-way system (2 x subs, 2 x 15" EVs and 2 x 12" Evs) so not sure where the 4-way system idea came from.

However, there's another reason why I need to sort out the mids and tops - because the band (all 4 of us) own the 4 Electrovoice speakers and it won't really be acceptable to use these speakers for my own PA Hire so I have to source alternatives without having to spend what we did on the EVs. So that's why firstly I was going to sort out a 1000W mid cab to run at 4 Ohms so that I can get the most out of the Peavey PV3800 (which can pump out 1300W @ 4 Ohms per channel). The same was going to be done for the 12" cab - 1000W for the tops @ 4 Ohms. If these were a success I'd duplicate the process. This would then give me replacement, higher powered system that would hopefully service my requirements.

If I'm barking up the wrong tree with my plans, I'd rather be told now and save myself a lot of expense and hassle in the long run.


Posted By: Elliot Thompson
Date Posted: 19 July 2012 at 11:32pm

Originally posted by George C George C wrote:

thanks for replies to my 'stupid question', great information, some I knew - lots more confirmed what I thought..... <div id="LCS_336D0C35_8A85_403a_B9D2_65C292C39087_communicationDiv">
 
Thumbs Up

George c


There is nothing stupid about your question.

I use capacitors on any driver that is not crossed below 2.5 kHz

Best Regards,



-------------
Elliot Thompson


Posted By: lycantheleopard
Date Posted: 19 July 2012 at 11:33pm
you are indeed barking up the wrong tree imo.
 
four way to me would be the following. your subs, your fifteen mid cabs, your 12 top cabs as you call them, and whatever horn or tweeter rounds out the top end.  if only using the 12s and fifteens of the ev rig, you'd be losing a lot of upper end detail and clarity and i dont think you'd settle for that.
 
i totally understand wanting your own rig, and that is basicly what i suggested above with the two eighteens per side, two 12s perside, and a psd3006 per side.  that is three way, that is your own gear, and that would outrun the ev mids and tops very quickly.
 
what i dont quite get is why you want or think you want fifteen mids and 12 tops? that is done in a lot of larger club rigs but you would then have to buy more amps, figure out how to stack it all safely, find a horn that can keep up with that much midrange energy, and passive crossovers to go between the twelves and the tweeters or horns you will absolutely need to finish off the top end.
 
with the dual eighteen, dual 12 and one horn approach, you have a nicely stackable system, you can run one peavey to each sub cab but please be careful as i said because the eminence killamax ratings are inflated and unsafe imo, and one to the 12 and horns through a passive crossover.  or, and this is how i would do it, buy a peavey pv1500 or 900 and power the two psd 3006 horns off the outputs five and six of your crossover for ultimate control.
 
so, just to make sure we're on the same page.
 
outputs one and two each go to a peavey pv3800 which goes to a dual eighteen subwoofer cabinet.
 
outputs three and four go to left and right channels of a third peavey 3800 which powers two 12 midbass/midrange speakers per side.
 
outputs five and six go to a peavey pv900 that powers a single eminence psd3006 on each side.
 
hope that clears up my intent.


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 20 July 2012 at 9:13am
Right, okay - I understand your point but I've already got 3 x Peavey PV3800 amps, so why would I replace that with a less powerful model? Anyway, the way we stack the system is one on top of the other (sub, 15 & 12 - a stack each side of the stage) and hold them all dwn with wrench straps and they're as solid as hell. The reason for the 15s was because we couldn't afford another set of ZX3s (the 12s) at 1300 pounds sterling a pair. So to compromise we bought a set of secondhand ZX5s (15s) that became available at half that price and thinking they were going to receive a lot of the mid frequencies we didn't think it a problem.






Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 20 July 2012 at 4:08pm
Ah sorry i miss read your post, the other amp would be an additional purchase. Then id have to buy another rack to house all these amps and add to the already stupidly heavy amp system that we have. All Im trying to do is make the most of the gear that Im allowed to use and try and find a way of getting the most out of what's available for me to buy and build without breaking the bank. If i can improve the system by getting it all to run at 4 ohms and making the most of the amps in a 3-way system then even better.


Posted By: lycantheleopard
Date Posted: 20 July 2012 at 9:13pm
you could source a passive crossover from like..radian makes them i think, at 1.2 khz, and then your mids and highs could be powered off the third peavey, negating the need for a fouth amp.  it would probably sound 98 percent as good and be easier to set up..i just like that final bit of control..and your current crossover unit could do it so i suggested it.
 
this would go right back to your orriginal questian, how to wire up two speakers and a horn.  well, you would go from the input on the cabinet to the crossover, then out to the dual fifteens from one side, and out to the horn from the other.  most crossovers are designed for eight ohms, but i believe the above suggested radian unit can do a four ohm midrange/midbass section.


Posted By: Elliot Thompson
Date Posted: 20 July 2012 at 10:00pm
Andygee70 seems to be more of a Rave sound system whereas lycantheleopard focuses on small pubs.

Large rave sound systems require a lot of mid-bass, which is why it is common to separate the midrange into two frequencies (12-inch for higher mid-range & 15-inch for lower mid-range).

Sound systems that cater for live work (particularly rock) will use 12-inch driver in a non-horn-loaded bin with a double-eighteen inch reflex. This is usually more preferred than a 15-inch due to having the least amount of mid-bass and more extended highs.



Best Regards,


-------------
Elliot Thompson


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 20 July 2012 at 10:25pm
Ah i see, to the crossover is first in line to the 15s then to the HF driver if parallel? What Ohm will the cab be if all the drivers are 4 Ohm?


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 20 July 2012 at 10:46pm
What do you mean by rave system? Do you mean a bigger system or one dedicated to pre-recorded music? Because Im looking for a system for bands. We've got all the hardware, shure, AKG, Sennheiser and Audix mics, all the cables, DI boxes and monitors.


Posted By: Elliot Thompson
Date Posted: 20 July 2012 at 11:01pm

Originally posted by Andygee70 Andygee70 wrote:

Ah i see, to the crossover is first in line to the 15s then to the HF driver if parallel? What Ohm will the cab be if all the drivers are 4 Ohm?



If you use a capacitor on the high frequency driver, the nominal impedance, on two 15-inch 8-ohm drivers, with the high frequency driver is 4 ohms.

Best Regards,   

-------------
Elliot Thompson


Posted By: Elliot Thompson
Date Posted: 20 July 2012 at 11:11pm

Originally posted by Andygee70 Andygee70 wrote:

What do you mean by rave system? Do you mean a bigger system or one dedicated to pre-recorded music? Because Im looking for a system for bands. We've got all the hardware, shure, AKG, Sennheiser and Audix mics, all the cables, DI boxes and monitors.


If you are not familiar with a rave sound system, they focus on using a 12 & 15-inch at different frequencies. If you are doing a live bands use either a 12 or 15-inch for midrange.

Best Regards,

-------------
Elliot Thompson


Posted By: lycantheleopard
Date Posted: 20 July 2012 at 11:13pm
for as low as you will probably wantto cross over from a pair of 12s, i dont reccomend a capasitor, but suggest a real passive crossover.  two fifteens or twelves each eight ohm, run through a passive crossover, with an eight ohm horn driver, will end up at four ohms.  the midbass/midrange drivers usually dictate the impeedence of the cabinet because they use the most power.


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 20 July 2012 at 11:19pm
So you're suggesting a capacitor rather than a crossover?


Posted By: Elliot Thompson
Date Posted: 20 July 2012 at 11:25pm

Originally posted by lycantheleopard lycantheleopard wrote:

for as low as you will probably wantto cross over from a pair of 12s, i dont reccomend a capasitor, but suggest a real passive crossover.



A capacitor is a part of the crossover. It is for the high frequency driver. It does not have anything to with any other driver which it is not attached to.

Best Regards,



-------------
Elliot Thompson


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 20 July 2012 at 11:27pm
Ah, i see, so a passive crossover and wired from speakon inputs to the 15s then to the crossover and to the HF drivers in parallel?


Posted By: Elliot Thompson
Date Posted: 20 July 2012 at 11:33pm

Originally posted by Andygee70 Andygee70 wrote:

So you're suggesting a capacitor rather than a crossover?


If you are looking to protect your high frequency driver from getting bass frequencies, all you need is a capacitor.

If you are looking to manipulate the frequencies in your 15-inch drivers, a passive crossover will be best.

Good passive crossovers are very expensive due to being capable of handling a lot of power.

This is a photo of a passive crossover burnt due to too much power.



Best Regards,

-------------
Elliot Thompson


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 1:17am
Okay, Im getting a lot of information overload at the moment. Am i right in thinking that my digital crossover unit would sufficiently send the right frequency to the 15s (provided i give it the right range) then all i would need is a capacitor?


Posted By: Elliot Thompson
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 7:22am


Originally posted by Andygee70 Andygee70 wrote:

Okay, Im getting a lot of information overload at the moment.


I agree.

Your question was already answered on the first page. I have no idea how your 15-inch drivers came into play when all you needed was a protection from your tweeter getting bass frequencies.

I am stopping here for as I stated in my first reply...

Originally posted by Elliot Thompson Elliot Thompson wrote:

Hi.

If you are looking for a simplistic method, buy a capacitor. Attach the capacitor between the positive terminal of the tweeter and, positive wire of the loudspeaker cable.

Pending on where you would like your tweeter crossed, you can purchase one of the following capacitors:

These are rough estimate figures

5.0uF = 4 kHz

4.0uF = 5 kHz

3.5uF = 5.5 kHz

3uF = 6.5 kHz

2.5uF = 8 kHz

2.0uF = 10 kHz

http://www.bluearan.co.uk/index.php?browsemode=category&category=Speaker_Components&masthead=Crossover_Components&subheadnew=Capacitors" rel="nofollow - http://www.bluearan.co.uk/index.php?browsemode=category&category=Speaker_Components&masthead=Crossover_Components&subheadnew=Capacitors


Best Regards,




Here is my second reply...

Originally posted by Elliot Thompson Elliot Thompson wrote:


Originally posted by Andygee70 Andygee70 wrote:

Ah i see, to the crossover is first in line to the 15s then to the HF driver if parallel? What Ohm will the cab be if all the drivers are 4 Ohm?



If you use a capacitor on the high frequency driver, the nominal impedance, on two 15-inch 8-ohm drivers, with the high frequency driver is 4 ohms.

Best Regards,   



Please don't make something simple turn into something complicated.






That is all you need.

Best Regards,


-------------
Elliot Thompson


Posted By: _djk_
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 7:56am
"That is all you need."

Better performance is available with better networks.


-------------
djk


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 8:34am
Originally posted by _djk_ _djk_ wrote:

"That is all you need."

Better performance is available with better networks.


So what are the better networks available? Are you referring to a crossoveror an alternative?


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 8:51am
Ahhh, I see how the crossover works now, you have the signal coming in from the speakon, then you have 2 sets of outputs to the 'split' signal a '+ & -' to the HF driver and the other to the woofers which are then linked in parallel.


Posted By: _djk_
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 11:41am
"So what are the better networks available? Are you referring to a crossoveror an alternative?"

A better network would be one that is designed for the specific parts to be used, one size does not fit all.

An example may help you see what I mean here:

A LR24 transfer function is to be desired.

A 6.5" woofer with a Q=0.5 12dB/oct low-pass combined with the acoustic roll-off of the driver gives the LR24 low-pass function.

The acoustic roll-off of the horn-loaded tweeter combined with an 18dB Butterworth high-pass gives the LR24 high-pass function.

Levels are matched with an L-pad between the crossover high-pass and the tweeter. A parallel resistor with the woofer was used to adjust the Q of the low-pass filter and damp the ringing of same.

The complete network has 2 inductors, 3 capacitors, and 3 resistors (2 of which are composites of 2 values).

The pad values were determined with a commercial L-pad in circuit, adjusted while watching an analyzer, and then fine-tuned by ear while  listening to a good recording of a snare drum. The L-pad was then measured and replaced with fixed resistors, the non-standard values required paralleling the next higher closest standard value with a standard value about 10x higher in value to bring it down to the desired custom value.


-------------
djk


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 11:58am
Originally posted by _djk_ _djk_ wrote:

"So what are the better networks available? Are you referring to a crossoveror an alternative?"

A better network would be one that is designed for the specific parts to be used, one size does not fit all.

An example may help you see what I mean here:

A LR24 transfer function is to be desired.

A 6.5" woofer with a Q=0.5 12dB/oct low-pass combined with the acoustic roll-off of the driver gives the LR24 low-pass function.

The acoustic roll-off of the horn-loaded tweeter combined with an 18dB Butterworth high-pass gives the LR24 high-pass function.

Levels are matched with an L-pad between the crossover high-pass and the tweeter. A parallel resistor with the woofer was used to adjust the Q of the low-pass filter and damp the ringing of same.

The complete network has 2 inductors, 3 capacitors, and 3 resistors (2 of which are composites of 2 values).

The pad values were determined with a commercial L-pad in circuit, adjusted while watching an analyzer, and then fine-tuned by ear while  listening to a good recording of a snare drum. The L-pad was then measured and replaced with fixed resistors, the non-standard values required paralleling the next higher closest standard value with a standard value about 10x higher in value to bring it down to the desired custom value.


Thanks djk,

That post right there has just proved to me I'm biting off far more that I can chew and will leave sleeping dogs lie.

Thanks for the advice btw.


Posted By: _djk_
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 12:14pm
The crossover can make or break a design, and is as much an art as it is a science.

-------------
djk


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 12:21pm
Originally posted by _djk_ _djk_ wrote:

The crossover can make or break a design, and is as much an art as it is a science.


Yeah, well I thought doing all this was a pretty good idea which has gradually turned out to be an idea well past my understanding and probably would end up being a disaster.

Like I said thanks for the advice.


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 3:32pm
If the speaker drivers and HF driver are all 8 Ohms and are to be wired in parallel to bring the overall load down to 4 Ohms - does the crossover have to be 8 or 4 Ohms?


Posted By: audiomik
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 3:42pm
Originally posted by Andygee70 Andygee70 wrote:

If the speaker drivers and HF driver are all 8 Ohms and are to be wired in parallel to bring the overall load down to 4 Ohms - does the crossover have to be 8 or 4 Ohms?



You can build or buy ready made crossovers which have different nominal load impedances for each section.

You are asking for having your two 8 Ohm low frequency drivers connected in parallel which is then a 4 Ohms load.
The section filtering the frequency range to these then needs to be designed for a 4 Ohm load.

For your HF Driver, assuming you are only using one, this will need a crossover filter for an 8 Ohms load.

There are a few 'dual impedance' crossovers to do this which are ready made or you could use one of the calculator websites to build your own.

Hope this assists
Mik

-------------
Warning! May contain Nuts
plus springs, washers, screws, etc, etc.


Posted By: Earplug
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 3:46pm
Simplest thing is to parallel the speakers (giving 4 ohm) and then connect something like this:

http://www.bluearan.co.uk/index.php?id=BMAF130&browsemode=manufacturer" rel="nofollow - http://www.bluearan.co.uk/index.php?id=BMAF130&browsemode=manufacturer

between the speakers and the tweeter.




-------------
Earplugs Are For Wimps!


Posted By: audiomik
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 3:55pm
Earplug

in the first post by the OP:
So, my problem lies in wanting to build a mid range speaker cabinet (woodwork sorted) that will house 2 x 15" 500W speakers @ 8 Ohms and a 45W 1" Tweeter @ 8 Ohms (all Eminence).

Somehow think your suggestion both won't have sufficient power rating or the correct impedance matching

Mik

-------------
Warning! May contain Nuts
plus springs, washers, screws, etc, etc.


Posted By: Earplug
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 4:07pm
Originally posted by audiomik audiomik wrote:

Earplug

in the first post by the OP:
So, my problem lies in wanting to build a mid range speaker cabinet (woodwork sorted) that will house 2 x 15" 500W speakers @ 8 Ohms and a 45W 1" Tweeter @ 8 Ohms (all Eminence).

Somehow think your suggestion both won't have sufficient power rating or the correct impedance matching

Mik


Yeah, it may be a bit underpowered, but it is a mid-cab and we all know that 500W today is more like 100W of yester-year! LOL

Impedence should be ok for 8 ohm tweeter high-pass? Confused






-------------
Earplugs Are For Wimps!


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 5:59pm
Originally posted by Earplug Earplug wrote:

Originally posted by audiomik audiomik wrote:

Earplug

in the first post by the OP:
So, my problem lies in wanting to build a mid range speaker cabinet (woodwork sorted) that will house 2 x 15" 500W speakers @ 8 Ohms and a 45W 1" Tweeter @ 8 Ohms (all Eminence).

Somehow think your suggestion both won't have sufficient power rating or the correct impedance matching

Mik

Yeah, it may be a bit underpowered, but it is a mid-cab and we all know that 500W today is more like 100W of yester-year! LOL

Impedence should be ok for 8 ohm tweeter high-pass? Confused

 




Are you guys being serious or is it a thinly-veiled dig at my severe lack of knowledge? Smile

I thought a 1000W cab running at 4 Ohms (with a revised 2" HF driver as opposed to a 1" tweeter) had a bit of guts about it, or am I missing something?






Posted By: audiomik
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 6:22pm
Andy

yes, did see that you have revised your thoughts on your drivers.
However the same principles apply.

Have a look http://www.colomar.com/Shavano/crossover12db.html" rel="nofollow - 12dB per Octave Crossover Design to see what size the Inductors and capacitors you will need to use for your crossover if you use a passive one. See also the 'make your own Inductor' link at the bottom of the page.
You will also need an 'L pad' to match your Horn output to the LF Drivers.

To be honest, the cost of these sort of Components for the power rating you are asking about will be most likely more than you can buy an LMS and additional Power Amplifier for your HF.
This will then give you much better control of your 'Speaker boxes

Mik

-------------
Warning! May contain Nuts
plus springs, washers, screws, etc, etc.


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 21 July 2012 at 6:58pm
Originally posted by audiomik audiomik wrote:

Andy

yes, did see that you have revised your thoughts on your drivers.
However the same principles apply.

Have a look http://www.colomar.com/Shavano/crossover12db.html" rel="nofollow - 12dB per Octave Crossover Design to see what size the Inductors and capacitors you will need to use for your crossover if you use a passive one. See also the 'make your own Inductor' link at the bottom of the page.
You will also need an 'L pad' to match your Horn output to the LF Drivers.

To be honest, the cost of these sort of Components for the power rating you are asking about will be most likely more than you can buy an LMS and additional Power Amplifier for your HF.
This will then give you much better control of your 'Speaker boxes

Mik


I'm so far out of my depth here dude it's unreal! Ha ha!

I'm gonna use the 'Make your own speaker system' book i bought for 8 quid as a very large and impractical beer matt, and ridicule myself for even thinking that all this was a good idea. I'll stick to what I know best, which is hitting the b-jesus out of a load of wood, plastic and metal which comes in construction form called a drum kit.

I'll leave the above methinks to people who know better. Was a nice thought for a while, then reality bites and we move on to the next stupid idea.

Thanks for all the support  you guys have given and the odd curve ball I think I took full in the face.

Ta ta for now Smile


Posted By: lycantheleopard
Date Posted: 22 July 2012 at 9:01am
sorry to hear we've put you off building and tweeking! lol we are after all, speaker plans, and we only wanted to help! *cries* wheres that silly fake angry face emoticon..
 
seriously though, in my post where i detailed the use of an amp for lows, mids, and highs, that is by far the simplest way to achieve your goal and could totally be done within your time constraint.


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 22 July 2012 at 12:57pm
Originally posted by lycantheleopard lycantheleopard wrote:

sorry to hear we've put you off building and tweeking! lol we are after all, speaker plans, and we only wanted to help! *cries* wheres that silly fake angry face emoticon..
 
seriously though, in my post where i detailed the use of an amp for lows, mids, and highs, that is by far the simplest way to achieve your goal and could totally be done within your time constraint.


Thanks for the above, maybe I'm thinking about all this in the totally wrong way by putting the horse in front of the cart.

Because we bought three cracking PV amps on a deal and knowing the capability of the amps to run at 4 Ohms with a total potential output of nearly 8K (instead of the 4K/5K we currently have), I thought it logical to figure out a way of building the speakers to compliment the amps hence seeking advice on building 4 x 1000W cabinets to cover the mids & highs to go with the already upgraded bass bins (which was the easiest job in the world) with the Eminence Kilomax 18s.

I knew that the driver and horn loaded cabs would be more complicated, but not to the degree that you guys take it - which are to levels beyond my understanding. I'd even considered taking the guts out of a couple of old Peavey Messenger pairs (rated at about 500W @ 4 Ohms) and sticking them in a home-made cab and wire them up - at least the electronics would be there, plus HF drivers matched - and link in an internal speakon connection to hook up the speakers in line, with one external speakon coming from one channel of the amp. A voila! I get my 1000W speaker cabinet with 2 drivers and 2 HF drivers!

Another daft idea? Queue sniggers from the experts at the back! LOL


Posted By: Earplug
Date Posted: 22 July 2012 at 1:39pm
It´s really not that complicated. Just invest in an active 3-way stereo crossover. Smile

That way all you have to worry about is matching the amps and speakers and can avoid all the mind-boggling passive xover calculations.  (But don´t mention run-times and phase!) LOL  Tongue  LOL






-------------
Earplugs Are For Wimps!


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 22 July 2012 at 11:46pm
Originally posted by Earplug Earplug wrote:

It´s really not that complicated. Just invest in an active 3-way stereo crossover. Smile

That way all you have to worry about is matching the amps and speakers and can avoid all the mind-boggling passive xover calculations.  (But don´t mention run-times and phase!) LOL  Tongue  LOL



Very good, lol!

Okay, but I guess it's quite difficult to get an active 3-way stereo crossover in the UK (all google searches comes up with digital units to put in flightcases).

On a seperate note, my crossover is set at the following frequencies:

Subs - 20Hz to 127Hz

ZX5s (15s) - 127Hz to 16.5Khz

ZX3s (12s) - 119Hz to 17.2Khz

Would I potentially be able to load the mid range cabinet with just 15" drivers and no HF driver without losing a lot of the guitar detail, because the guitar sounds superb through the ZX5s. How much does the guitar detail owe to the HF driver?


Posted By: lycantheleopard
Date Posted: 23 July 2012 at 8:01am
with those crossover points, you are basicly getting everything from both zx5 and zx3 cabs, neither is a mid or a high, both are mid/high cabs, and thats why you like it, its got balls, its got detailed upper end, and its using what you own to its full potential.
 
the top end of a guitar absolutely comes out through the high frequency driver in the zx5 so please dont lose that good sound you already have.
 
with that unit, you own a threeway stereo crossover.  subs from 20 hz to 90 hz..fifteens from 100 hz to 1.2 khz, and horns from 1.2 khz to 20 khz..or something close to that.  this avoids all passive confusion, gives you the ability to swap drivers and play with the cabs till your happy, and means you only have to buyan amp since the crossover is already sorted


Posted By: Andygee70
Date Posted: 23 July 2012 at 10:06am
I know the present system works exceptionally well, but my predicament is that when i do my own pa hire, I'll be allowed to use the amps and the subs but not the electro-voice speakers. So as much as the set-up is great i have to find an alternative speaker system so that i can maximize the amps that i can use (thus the hope of getting all speakers to work off 4 ohms). Which brings me to the original question of eventually constructing 4 cabs at a 1000w each with 4 Ohm impedance (to get the most out of my three amps that are rated at 1300w per channel at 4 ohms). So the question was more about the configuration of the mid / high cabs and speakers to be loaded in them.


Posted By: Earplug
Date Posted: 23 July 2012 at 2:34pm
Originally posted by Andygee70 Andygee70 wrote:

Originally posted by Earplug Earplug wrote:

It´s really not that complicated. Just invest in an active 3-way stereo crossover. Smile

That way all you have to worry about is matching the amps and speakers and can avoid all the mind-boggling passive xover calculations.  (But don´t mention run-times and phase!) LOL  Tongue  LOL



Very good, lol!

Okay, but I guess it's quite difficult to get an active 3-way stereo crossover in the UK (all google searches comes up with digital units to put in flightcases).



Yes, the crossover should go in a rack (along with the amps!  Smile).

Here´s a few:

http://www.ebay.co.uk/sch/i.html?_nkw=3-way+stereo+active+crossover&_sacat=0&_odkw=3-way+srereo+active+crossover&_osacat=0" rel="nofollow - http://www.ebay.co.uk/sch/i.html?_nkw=3-way+stereo+active+crossover&_sacat=0&_odkw=3-way+srereo+active+crossover&_osacat=0

Or:

http://www.thomann.de/es/search_dir.html?sid=777ce30dbab1713a0ee1d4871bdedc75&xsid=777ce30dbab1713a0ee1d4871bdedc75&sw=crossovers&x=0&y=0" rel="nofollow - http://www.thomann.de/es/search_dir.html?sid=777ce30dbab1713a0ee1d4871bdedc75&xsid=777ce30dbab1713a0ee1d4871bdedc75&sw=crossovers&x=0&y=0










-------------
Earplugs Are For Wimps!


Posted By: audiomik
Date Posted: 23 July 2012 at 2:47pm
Or:
PM Tony Wilkes on here about the dB-Mark ones
http://www.forteaudio.eu/ and follow the link to 'Loudspeaker Processors'.

You will find some good reports by users of these in various threads on here.

Mik

-------------
Warning! May contain Nuts
plus springs, washers, screws, etc, etc.



Print Page | Close Window

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 12.06 - https://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2023 Web Wiz Ltd. - https://www.webwiz.net