Print Page | Close Window

Small Line Array Design

Printed From: Speakerplans.com
Category: General
Forum Name: Advanced Discussion
Forum Description: Advanced discussion area for higher lifeforms
URL: https://forum.speakerplans.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=108621
Printed Date: 27 March 2026 at 4:54am
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 12.08 - https://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: Small Line Array Design
Posted By: csijo
Subject: Small Line Array Design
Date Posted: 08 July 2024 at 8:19am
Saludos a todos los amigos del foro, estoy por fabricar un proyecto para un sistema de altavoces array pequeño, he conseguido 16 altavoces yamaha NX-E130 full rango, con un  rango de frecuencia entre 100 Hz a 25 kHz y 30 Watts RMS por cada pareja de controladores. 
Quiero fabricar un par de sistemas compuestos por 16 drivers cada uno y quisiera consultarles
¿Cuál sería la forma más eficiente de diseñar el sistema line array para obtener la mayor cantidad de decibeles posibles?

1. Haciendo un arreglo vertical de 8 líneas de drivers que cada uno lleva dos altavoces full rango de 2 pulgadas uno al lado del otro sin ningún problema. centímetro de separación entre los chasis de los controladores.

o

2. Haciendo un arreglo vertical de 16 altavoces de 2 pulgadas en línea que llevan al menos 1 cm de separación entre el chasis de cada driver ?

Me gustaría escuchar sus opiniones. Les dejo imágenes relacionadas al proyecto.
Por cierto estoy tratando de subir imagenes a este post y no he conseguido lograrlo.






-------------
Audio Fanatics, Bass lover



Replies:
Posted By: APC321
Date Posted: 08 July 2024 at 8:34am
Translation:
Greetings to all the friends of the forum, I am about to build a project for a small array speaker system, I have obtained 16 Yamaha NX-E130 full range speakers, with a frequency range between 100 Hz to 25 kHz and 30 Watts RMS for each pair of drivers.
I want to manufacture a couple of systems composed of 16 drivers each and I would like to consult with you
What would be the most efficient way to design the line array system to obtain the highest number of decibels possible?

1. Making a vertical arrangement of 8 lines of drivers that each carry two 2-inch full-range speakers side by side without any problem. centimeter of separation between the controller chassis.

either

2. Making a vertical arrangement of 16 2-inch speakers in line that have at least 1 cm of separation between the chassis of each driver?

I would like to hear your opinions here I leave you images related to the project.




Posted By: Conanski
Date Posted: 08 July 2024 at 11:06pm
This will be a line source speaker not a line array.. it won't be nearly large enough to produce line array behavior across most of the spectrum.

The design ideals with these speaker types are a single tall column of drivers with center to center distances as close as possible... which means drivers frames touching(no separation of drivers), this is important as it increases the range of frequencies over which the column produces a coherent wavefront. Even with this done the system will produce a lot of comb filtering above 7khz were sound wavelenths are less than the driver c-c spacing. 
And these small drivers won't do very well at low fequencies, you should expect to need additional support below 200-300hz. 
Lastly don't expect a lot of SPL, these will not really qualify as a PA speaker.. more of a loud home audio/studio speaker.


Posted By: VECTORDJ
Date Posted: 09 July 2024 at 2:49am
Look at Bose MA12 for ideas....Just a bunch of Small Drivers...Soud fine for Church or small Karaoke Bar....Not for Hard Rock Bands.


Posted By: fudge22
Date Posted: 11 July 2024 at 9:06pm

Quote This will be a line source speaker not a line array.. it won't be nearly large enough to produce line array behavior across most of the spectrum.

 

Which manufacturer’s marketing does this snippet of technical information come from? An array can be defined as an arrangement of similar objects, usually in rows and columns. As such a columns of loudspeakers, irrespective of size. can be defined as an array. If there is only a single column, line array seems appropriate.

As for the theory, Olson’s oft quoted book Acoustical Engineering refers to a straight-line source, which it says, may be made up of a large number of points of equal strength and phase on a line separated by equal and very small distances. If the number of sources n approach infinity and d, the distance between the sources, approaches zero in such a way that nd = l the limiting case is the line source. So, presumably line source is good. No mention of an array.

 

Quote The design ideals with these speaker types are a single tall column of drivers with center to center distances as close as possible... which means drivers frames touching(no separation of drivers), this is important as it increases the range of frequencies over which the column produces a coherent wavefront. Even with this done the system will produce a lot of comb filtering above 7khz were sound wavelenths are less than the driver c-c spacing.

 

The theory behind centre to centre spacing presumes that the sources are ideal points. That is, their size is insignificant to the wavelength. As such, no sound is radiated from the gap between the points. In practical loudspeakers, at frequencies where the spacing between elements becomes significant, each drive unit can not be considered a point source, and imparts directivity. You can’t ignore that the edge of the drive unit is also radiating sound, not just the centre. If the drive units are touching there is no clear centre to centre spacing.



Posted By: Lucasdude
Date Posted: 11 July 2024 at 9:48pm
The first thing I thought of when I read the description of what you had was the old Bose 802. They were an 8 driver speaker, with 2 slightly angled baffles of 4 drivers for better coverage. I seem to remember the drivers being 1ohm wired in series for 8ohms total, but with a bit of series/parallel wiring you can choose a few different final figures.
   Love em or hate em, they sure were popular back in the day!


Posted By: csijo
Date Posted: 12 July 2024 at 3:23pm


-------------
Audio Fanatics, Bass lover


Posted By: snowflake
Date Posted: 12 July 2024 at 5:06pm
google Keele's CBT array - constant beamwidth technology


Posted By: julius111
Date Posted: 13 July 2024 at 7:10pm
Originally posted by fudge22 fudge22 wrote:

As for the theory, Olson’s oft quoted book Acoustical Engineering refers to a straight-line source, which it says, may be made up of a large number of points of equal strength and phase on a line separated by equal and very small distances. If the number of sources n approach infinity and d, the distance between the sources, approaches zero in such a way that nd = l the limiting case is the line source. So, presumably line source is good. No mention of an array.

The theory behind centre to centre spacing presumes that the sources are ideal points. That is, their size is insignificant to the wavelength. As such, no sound is radiated from the gap between the points. In practical loudspeakers, at frequencies where the spacing between elements becomes significant, each drive unit can not be considered a point source, and imparts directivity. You can’t ignore that the edge of the drive unit is also radiating sound, not just the centre. If the drive units are touching there is no clear centre to centre spacing.


hi there, i am interested to learn from this, but could not think of how this would work out in building something.

afaik, as wavelength becomes smaller with higher frequencies, you would get a lot of lobes of phase cancellation between the speakers. for bass, those speakers are too small to give significant output. 

could you point out an example of speaker where this is put into practice?

best, Julius



Posted By: fudge22
Date Posted: 16 July 2024 at 3:49pm

Quote hi there, i am interested to learn from this, but could not think of how this would work out in building something.

 

There are plenty of acoustic theory books, if that is what you want to learn, assuming that you have some knowledge of mathematics. If all you are interested in is building loudspeaker cabinets, fortunately any drive unit, in any box, will make a sound.

 

Quote afaik, as wavelength becomes smaller with higher frequencies, you would get a lot of lobes of phase cancellation between the speakers. for bass, those speakers are too small to give significant output.

 

Off axis cancellations are what gives a line array its directivity. Outside, discrete side lobes are not much of a problem if they are outside the required coverage area. Inside, reducing them improves intelligibility.

 

Whether the mentioned loudspeakers provide sufficient level, or low-end response, depends on the intended use. Not all situations demand levels that will cause early onset hearing loss.



Posted By: julius111
Date Posted: 17 July 2024 at 3:07pm
Originally posted by fudge22 fudge22 wrote:

There are plenty of acoustic theory books, if that is what you want to learn, assuming that you have some knowledge of mathematics. If all you are interested in is building loudspeaker cabinets, fortunately any drive unit, in any box, will make a sound.

 

thanks, i recently finished bob mccarthys book, which was a bit more helpful in learning than your comment.


Originally posted by fudge22 fudge22 wrote:

Off axis cancellations are what gives a line array its directivity. Outside, discrete side lobes are not much of a problem if they are outside the required coverage area. Inside, reducing them improves intelligibility.

Whether the mentioned loudspeakers provide sufficient level, or low-end response, depends on the intended use. Not all situations demand levels that will cause early onset hearing loss.

 

again, thanks for answering, but i guess this means there is nothing for me to learn from you.



Posted By: csijo
Date Posted: 18 July 2024 at 7:55pm
La idea de este par de altavoces con 16 controladores yamaha cada uno es usarlos entre 200 hz y 18 khz. 

-------------
Audio Fanatics, Bass lover


Posted By: julius111
Date Posted: 18 July 2024 at 8:28pm
so, following snowflakes suggestion of constant beamwidth, at first i did not see something one would replicate in small scale

http://www.xlrtechs.com/dbkeele.com/CBT.php" rel="nofollow - http://www.xlrtechs.com/dbkeele.com/CBT.php

but then, on the page above, i saw that jbl has a series of loudspeakers that uses (if i got that right) electronic delay instead of acoustical (in form of building an arc shaped speaker), with small speaker boxes consisting of not more speakers than csijo has

https://jblpro.com/product_families/cbt-series-passive-controlled-coverage-columns" rel="nofollow - https://jblpro.com/product_families/cbt-series-passive-controlled-coverage-columns

in the past, i have used diy amp boards with dsp (tinysine, wondom), which could be used to build a small speaker box of vertical aligned drivers. a board with 4 channels could run a speaker with 7 drivers (pattern 4 - 3 - 2 - 1 - 2 - 3 - 4) and delay the input signal according to the position in the array.

asking the forum, is this something that could work, or have i smoked the wrong tree?

cheers! J.



Posted By: Elliot Thompson
Date Posted: 19 July 2024 at 4:10am

One of things that many do is load as many loudspeakers remotely feasible on an amplifier and, crank it up. Using one amplifier for each loudspeaker allows you to accomplish more creativity in terms of performance. It is a more costly method that the cheapskate mentality of many sound professionals refuse to do. This in turn, will lead to a lot reasons not to do it. However, you must follow your own path and choose what is best for your requirements. Your method would work!


Best Regards,   



-------------
Elliot Thompson


Posted By: julius111
Date Posted: 20 July 2024 at 5:29am
thanks for your feedback!

while reading on other subjects (i have a lot of free time a.t.m.), i came across a link to a software which would allow for simulating the arrangement of speakers. it even mentions CBT array in the manual:

https://kimmosaunisto.net/Software/VituixCAD/VituixCAD_help_20.html#Driver_layout" rel="nofollow - https://kimmosaunisto.net/Software/VituixCAD/VituixCAD_help_20.html#Driver_layout

might be worth trying, as it‘s donation-based software.

cheers, Julius.


Posted By: fatfreddiescat
Date Posted: 20 July 2024 at 9:34am
Vituixcad is an awesome peice of software and would be invaluable for a project such as yours, lots of info on diyaudio in regards to small line arrays as well as the author of Vituixcad being active on there.


Posted By: Elliot Thompson
Date Posted: 20 July 2024 at 12:09pm

As VituixCAD allows you to import numerous measured results from a wide variety of programs, the end results will be more accurate than, focusing solely on a static simulation program.


Definitely more next level of design that many are not doing when building a loudspeaker system.


Best Regards,  



-------------
Elliot Thompson


Posted By: csijo
Date Posted: 14 August 2024 at 10:39am

Queridos amigos de Speakersplans.com,

Quiero expresar mi más sincero agradecimiento a todos ustedes por su invaluable ayuda y la información que me brindaron. Su conocimiento y disposición para aclarar mis dudas han sido fundamentales para mi proyecto.

Desde aquellos que compartieron su experiencia técnica hasta quienes me proporcionaron enlaces útiles y consejos prácticos, cada uno de sus aportes ha sido de gran valor. Estoy realmente impresionado por la amabilidad y el profesionalismo que caracteriza a esta comunidad.

Gracias a sus sugerencias y orientaciones, ahora tengo una comprensión mucho más clara y sólida de los temas que me preocupaban. No podría haber avanzado sin su apoyo.

Ahora me preocupa otro tema, el diseño del filtro de frecuencias crossover para este tipo de altavoz y estaba pensando en
diseñar y construir un filtro pasivo divisor de frecuencias de 24 dB por octava (4to orden) con una sola vía para un rango de frecuencias entre 150 Hz y 20 kHz para altavoces de 250 vatios RMS con impedancias entre 4 y 8 ohmios, creo que ese tipo de filtro normalmente no se vende y me tocara fabricarlo y he estado investigando un poco y he encontrado esto


Para el Filtro Pasa-Alto (HPF) a 150 Hz:

Para una impedancia nominal de 4 ohmios: C= 265 μF y  L1= 4,24 mH
Para una impedancia nominal de 8 ohmios: C1= 132 μF y    L1= 8,48 mH

Para el Filtro Pasa-Bajo (LPF) a 20 kHz:
Para una impedancia nominal de 4 ohmios: 
do2= 0,2 μF y   L2= 15,9 μH
Para una impedancia nominal de 8 ohmios:  C2= 0,1 μF y   L2= 31.8 μH

Ahora el tema seria donde conseguir sobre todas las bobinas y condensadores con esos valores aquí en españa.

Les dejo unas fotitos de lo que he ido adelantando



-------------
Audio Fanatics, Bass lover


Posted By: julius111
Date Posted: 15 August 2024 at 7:48pm
hey,
great to hear you are making good progress!

the filter you mention, i think it is a 12dB/oct circuit?
i use this tool, it is in german but you might be able to still use it
https://www.jobst-audio.de/tool/frequenzweiche/frequenzweichen-rechner" rel="nofollow - https://www.jobst-audio.de/tool/frequenzweiche/frequenzweichen-rechner

it is basic though, there is a whole art to making analog crossovers. my knowledge of electronics is limited, i now use dsp whenever i can.



Print Page | Close Window

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 12.08 - https://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2026 Web Wiz Ltd. - https://www.webwiz.net